Tags
Well, the quick answer is ‘no’. But, in the spirit of Free Your Parenting, I’m now going to tell you why!
Firstly, it’s because breastmilk is 88% water so, as long as your baby is feeding efficiently enough (check that latch!), frequently enough and for long enough at each feed, then they’ll get more than enough water from your milk. This fact has been proven many times, in
many different climates by many different pieces of research.
Secondly, it’s not actually that good to give water to a baby under the age of 6 months:
- Water fills up a baby’s stomach with no-calorie fluid, meaning he won’t be able to fill it with high-calorie fluid, which can affect his weight gain
- If your baby doesn’t feed as much at the breast because of being full of water, you could find you get problems maintaining your milk supply
- Even if you sterilise water by boiling it, and the vessel you offer it to your baby in, it will never be as bug-free as breastmilk is
- In very newborn babies, supplemental water has been associated with increased bilirubin levels, also known as infant jaundice
Once your baby is starting on solids, ideally you offer water alongside meals, but remembering that it’s ‘just for fun until they’re one’. In other words, you’re still not aiming to supplement breastfeeding. Instead, you’re helping your little one learn to drink from something other than a breast. (See Five Tips for Getting a Baby to Drink from a Cup)
NB: The situation is slightly different for formula fed babies. In general, you don’t want to because, again, it’s fewer calories. However, you may need to give them small amounts if it’s very hot weather and there are concerns about possible dehydration.
If you do give a young baby water, then be careful what you use. In the UK, the safest is cooled, boiled tap water. The situation becomes far more complicated when you start looking at bottled waters because you need to make sure that the mineral content isn’t too high for their tiny bodies to cope with.
Edited to add: I have just found this brilliant article by the Rehydration Project, which explains that breastfed babies actually need ^less^ water than older babies or adults because of how breastmilk works. Essentially, breastmilk has very few solutes in it (dissolved minerals in the food and drink we ingest), which means that less fluid is needed for their kidneys to flush them out. So, there you have it, breastmilk really is better for babies in hot weather than water!

What do you mean about bottled waters and the minerals being too much to cope with? I buy springwater and i was intending on giving to my baby eventually. Can you share a link to more info please? I want to avoid tap water because of the added flouride, and boiling it simply further concentrates this additive.
Hi Ali
It’s difficult to know. I did a lot of research, and all the advice I found just said to be careful with very few specifics. It sounds from this link that spring water is best avoided because they don’t have to write the mineral levels on them, and they can fluctuate. I’ll do some really thorough research into this for you, and write a post on it next week, if that helps? I’ll email you when it’s up.
Clare
thankyou, yes! :)
:)
Just wondering what about a breastfed baby who is fed on a schedule, not on demand. Would you give water?
Thanks
That’s an interesting question. I’m trying to work out in what way water would be different to breastmilk in a routine-fed baby’s mind. Obviously, if your baby appears to be dehydrated in any way, then it is imperative that you give him some fluids of some description and, without a doubt, breastmilk would be better for him than water and I can’t think of a reason why you might want to choose water over breastmilk. I may well be missing something here, though, so let me know if I am! :)
This was a hypothetical question. I am feeding on demand personally but I know lots of mums who feed on a schedule. So the baby has a breastfeed say at 10 and another one say 3 hours later. So if the mum does not want to offer the breast outside scheduled times (because she believes the routine is important, or because she won’t breastfeed in public, or whatever), should she offer water – just like she would with a bottlefed baby?
(I am a student BFC so I thought this might be useful to know)
Thanks
Ah, OK. I’m going to do more in-depth research, but if she’s going to give her baby a bottle of water out of schedule, then she may as well give him a bottle of expressed breastmilk or just a breastfeed, which would be much, much better for him than water. I’ve heard it said (but can’t back this up at the moment) that the fluid in breastmilk is more easily absorbed by a young baby’s gut than water is, as well.
Thank you.
QUOTE: fluid in breastmilk is more easily absorbed by a young baby’s gut than water is END QUOTE – this is very interesting and useful to know.
I agree with you that giving breastmilk is better than water – and (if I understand that correctly) water is better than nothing :-)
I can’t back that quote up at the moment, though, Martina, so don’t hold me to it! I’m researching it at the moment.
Martina – see the edited post for a link to an article which does, indeed, explain why breastmilk is preferable to water when it comes to rehydrating a baby. :)
Thanks for the link
Pingback: Bottled water for babies « Free Your Parenting